Money Jars and the Curious Case of La Papillion’s Missing House

Money Jar

06 Dec Money Jars and the Curious Case of La Papillion’s Missing House

Just last week, Kyith, better known as his online moniker Investment Moats, shared an article on Facebook. It was a link back to La Papillion’s article published in his blog Bully the Bear in November last year.

The title of the article was ‘I have Zero Net-Worth‘. Extremely catchy, and had it originated from anyone else, I would have dismissed it as click bait immediately. But having come from not one but two doyens, I know it is definitely worth reading about.

Asset minus Liability

Now we all know that the definition of Net Worth is Assets minus Liabilities.

We know that trying to pick stocks can be very frustrating. Skip that frustration, get 21 ideas to finding profitable stocks in an instant. 

The math is simple. We take everything we own and subtract from there everything we owe. If the final figure is positive, we would have more assets than liabilities and our networth would be positive. What this means is if we sell off all our assets and use the income to pay back our loans, at the end of the day we will still have money left over in the bank.

Conversely, if the number turns out negative, we are actually in debt. The implication is that should creditors decide to call in all our debts at the same time, we will not have enough to repay even after selling off all our assets.

If you are a newbie to personal finance, calculating your networth is a good place to start getting a grasp on your financial standings.

Back to LP. In his article, he shared how he stumbled upon the realisation one day that his networth is zero. Like what we would all have done, LP added up his assets and liabilities. They work out to be like this.

Screen shot 2015-12-06 at AM 10.20.27

It did not take long for readers to realise that LP has left out a major ‘asset’ in his computation of his networth – his HDB flat. Had he taken that into consideration, his networth would have been radically different. It would have been very positive.

If you have not read the article, I strongly encourage you to head over for a better picture. There is also a very lively conversation going on in the comment section over there. Many have questioned the deliberate exclusion of his greatest asset. Here is a short summary. #thebestofLP #tohellwithnonbelievers.

Screen shot 2015-12-06 at AM 10.22.36

Screen shot 2015-12-06 at AM 10.22.54

Dustin Hoffman and the Money Jars

Behavioural Economist Richard Thaler was the first to come up with the concept of Mental Accounting. In his book Nudge, he shared an anecdote about Hollywood legends and long time friends Gene Hackman and Dustin Hoffman.

Gene recalled that many years ago, when they were both struggling actors, Dustin tried to borrow money from him for food. They were standing in Dustin’s kitchen and sitting on his shelf were money jars. The jars were labelled – Rent, Food, Utilities, Transport etc etc.

All the jars had money in them, all except the food jar. Dustin Hoffman had run out of money to buy food, and it was totally unthinkable him to remove money from other jars for food. His had inherited this habit from his parents and it had served him well. He would rather borrow.

Hear it from the guys themselves.

The comfortable way of looking at money

We practice mental accounting all the time. We have these little money jars in our heads where we compartmentalize money. Our brains do not have the computational ability to see money as individual units and in grouping them, we make money matters easier to comprehend.

Another awesome personal finance blogger Lionel has written a three part series about Money Jars. By predetermining how we want to spend our money, we remove the thinking from many money decisions later on. Money decisions become automatic. The battles within ourselves on whether to splurge on a holiday or a new bag we have been eyeing no longer wreck havoc on our psyche. We feel a lot better about money.

The idea is great and I have no doubts that it is an effective personal finance set up. However, I do want to caution that the idea will work well up to a point where things are humming along smoothly and all the jars are filling up well.

The complication sets in when one of the jar is emptied, like the case of Dustin Hoffman, or when we start taking debt (and the cost of money) into consideration.

Take for example a young couple saving up to get married. They do the money jar thingy with their finances. The thing is, they both have student loans outstanding. The logical thing to do would be to stop take any excess money to pay off the student loan because it is incurring the highest interest.

Unfortunately it is much more comfortable to see money piling up in the bank accounts. In the search for comfort, we make sub-optimal decisions about money.

The curious case of LP’s missing house

Human beings are creatures of comfort. It is a natural tendency to seek comfort in everything we do.

In choosing to do his sums this way, LP has effectively siphoned away his biggest asset and taken it off his balance sheet. Not only has he locked and sealed the HDB jar and labelled it untouchable, he has gone as far as the hide his biggest jar away from (his own) prying eyes. It is a very comforting thought indeed.

I just want to end off the article by saying that such creative-comforting accounting is not only practiced by individuals. Despite being subjected to accounting standards and regulations, many listed companies also engage in such ‘activities’. Case in point, companies who value their properties at cost despite the common understanding that the actual value has already appreciated significantly.

In doing so, they under declare their Net Asset Value (networth). Like LP, these companies are actually worth a lot more than they are made out to be. Our very own CNAV Investing Strategy identifies such companies to buy on the cheap. Find out more at our Value Investing Mastery Course.

image credit: homefirstcertified



Grant Yourself The Ability To Make 10 - 15 % Returns Annually. Lifetime Access. Learn at your convenience. Bag stock market profits with ease: Access Now!

New to investing and could use some free and useful guides? Check out: "How to start investing in Singapore"

  • Tacomob
    Posted at 15:08h, 06 December Reply

    Thanks for the reminder. We should constantly remind ourselves that our Mental Accounting Bias – despite of those straight ‘A’s we might have scored in school – might still lead us to commit dumb mistakes with our money. I start by not pretending to myself that some money is more important than others: it’s not. Sometimes I succeed in that, but often not.

    • Jon
      Posted at 00:08h, 07 December Reply

      Thanks for dropping by Tacamob, totally agree, all money is equally important.

      The only thing with living that way is that it becomes very cognitively taxing, having to constantly remind ourselves not to make these dumb money mistakes. Nevertheless, the least we can do is to try!

  • My Net Worth Is Only 5-Figure And I’m OK With It | The Turtle Investor
    Posted at 18:56h, 06 December Reply

    […] 1st December 2014 – haha! I had wanted to write a short post on it but had forgotten, until BigFatPurse wrote a piece on it […]

  • Temperament
    Posted at 11:00h, 07 December Reply

    That’s why most million dollars lottery winners ended up worst then before.
    So many of them if not all of them that there goes a saying, “Those that the God of Fortune wants to destroy, will bestows on them winning the million dollars lottery”
    The rest is history.

    Money easy comes, easy goes.
    That’s what happened to me with profit money from the market too.
    So try to remember WB’s 1st and 2nd rules, as much as possible.
    Kiasu Liu!
    There is no such thing as FOC money.
    Not even for the $million lottery winners.

  • Networth updated!
    Posted at 16:00h, 07 December Reply

    […] titled I’ve Zero networth is picked up in fb and started a few posts by other bloggers like BIGfatpurse and The Turtle Investor. They said it’s controversial, haha and I agree that it is so. I […]

  • How Far Would You Go to Drop Off a $1.29 Cheque?
    Posted at 09:13h, 04 April Reply

    […] way of thinking. Human beings are of course not fully rational all the time. We are experts at mental accounting. We do what makes us feel best rather than what is really […]

Post A Comment

Another popup!? 

We Are Sorry! But WAIT...

Since you are already reading, why not read on? You are probably reading an article on this site because you are interested in investing and personal finance.


If that's true, this value packed ebook, "Investing Your First $20,000" would definitely help you.


Simply enter your email below and we will send you the ebook plus insightful finance articles just like the one you were reading before this popup - right to your inbox. No more popups!


Try it. You can unsubscribe any time.

Good Job!

Thank You For Your Time

Do check your email for the ebook!